| New York City FC at Columbus Crew Wed, 07/22/2026 7:30 PM EDT | Wed, 07/22/2026 7:30 PM EDT | Columbus Crew SC | ScottsMiracle-Gro Field | Columbus | 5% | $20 |
| Chicago Fire at New York City FC Sat, 07/25/2026 7:30 PM EDT | Sat, 07/25/2026 7:30 PM EDT | New York City FC | Yankee Stadium | Bronx | 34% | $19 |
| Toronto FC at New York City FC Fri, 07/31/2026 7:30 PM EDT | Fri, 07/31/2026 7:30 PM EDT | New York City FC | Yankee Stadium | Bronx | 5% | $23 |
| Philadelphia Union at New York City FC Sun, 08/16/2026 6:30 PM EDT | Sun, 08/16/2026 6:30 PM EDT | New York City FC | Yankee Stadium | Bronx | 23% | $27 |
| New York City FC at FC Cincinnati Wed, 08/19/2026 7:30 PM EDT | Wed, 08/19/2026 7:30 PM EDT | FC Cincinnati | TQL Stadium | Cincinnati | Flat | $24 |
| New York City FC at New England Revolution Sun, 08/23/2026 4:30 PM EDT | Sun, 08/23/2026 4:30 PM EDT | New England Revolution | Gillette Stadium | Foxborough | 8% | $24 |
| New York City FC at Toronto FC Sat, 08/29/2026 7:30 PM EDT | Sat, 08/29/2026 7:30 PM EDT | Toronto FC | BMO Field | Old Toronto, Toronto | Flat | $26 |
| Nashville SC at New York City FC Fri, 09/04/2026 7:30 PM EDT | Fri, 09/04/2026 7:30 PM EDT | New York City FC | Yankee Stadium | Bronx | Flat | $17 |
| New England Revolution at New York City FC Wed, 09/09/2026 7:30 PM EDT | Wed, 09/09/2026 7:30 PM EDT | New York City FC | Citi Field | Flushing | Flat | $12 |
| New York City FC at Real Salt Lake Sat, 09/12/2026 7:30 PM MDT | Sat, 09/12/2026 7:30 PM MDT | Real Salt Lake | America First Field | Sandy | Flat | $31 |
| New York Red Bulls at New York City FC Fri, 09/18/2026 7:30 PM EDT | Fri, 09/18/2026 7:30 PM EDT | New York City FC | Yankee Stadium | Bronx | Flat | $48 |
| New York City FC at Atlanta United Sat, 09/26/2026 7:30 PM EDT | Sat, 09/26/2026 7:30 PM EDT | Atlanta United | Mercedes-Benz Stadium | Atlanta | 3% | $37 |
| New York City FC at Chicago Fire FC Sat, 10/10/2026 1:30 PM CDT | Sat, 10/10/2026 1:30 PM CDT | Chicago Fire FC | Soldier Field | Chicago | Flat | - |
| New York City FC at Inter Miami CF Wed, 10/14/2026 7:30 PM EDT | Wed, 10/14/2026 7:30 PM EDT | Inter Miami CF | Miami Freedom Park & Soccer Village | Miami | 4% | $51 |
| New York City FC at Orlando City SC Sat, 10/24/2026 7:30 PM EDT | Sat, 10/24/2026 7:30 PM EDT | Orlando City SC | Inter & Co Stadium | Orlando | Flat | $11 |
| Atlanta United FC at New York City FC (Venue TBD) Wed, 10/28/2026 7:30 PM EDT | Wed, 10/28/2026 7:30 PM EDT | New York City FC | Yankee Stadium | Bronx | Flat | $37 |
| CF Montreal at New York City FC (Venue TBD) Sat, 10/31/2026 12:00 AM EDT | Sat, 10/31/2026 12:00 AM EDT | New York City FC | Yankee Stadium | Bronx | Flat | $37 |
| Los Angeles FC at New York City FC (Rescheduled from 5/6, 10/17) Wed, 11/04/2026 7:30 PM EST | Wed, 11/04/2026 7:30 PM EST | New York City FC | Citi Field | Flushing | Flat | $73 |
| New York City FC at DC United Sat, 11/07/2026 4:00 PM EST | Sat, 11/07/2026 4:00 PM EST | DC United | Audi Field | Washington | Flat | $14 |
